From: Steve McIntyre

Sent: March 29, 2004 8:11 AM

To: Langenberg, Heike

Cc: Ross McKitrick

Subject: Re: Nature corrigendum Mann02478

Thanks for your reply. I would describe some of the points on methodology as being correct descriptions of procedures incorrectly described in the original article and therefore requiring a corrigendum item, but you've had an opportunity to consider the point and quite reasonably want to finalize this matter. I thought that I had also identified several errors in the short text of the corrigendum and included these in my comments. These would be trivial to correct and I think that it would be a good idea to do so (if this is not already done.) 

Regards, Steve McIntyre