'
Aug. 30, 2004 McIntyre to Ziemelis
Dear Karl, Could I please refresh this now
that the 2-3 weeks have passed. It is pretty crazy than Mann et al.
should have failed to provide the data items 1-3 that I
requested (although they have provided much that I didn't request). I
have repeatedly re-iterated the request so there are no grounds for
mis-understanding. It is crazy that Nature has left this unattended so
long - now nearly 9 months. I find it hard to understand why obtaining
compliance with your data policies should involved major editorial
policy consultation.
The Danish Meteorological Agency have
also taken an interest in replicating MBH98 and have communicated with
me on my efforts to replicate MBH98. I have accordingly copied these
recent requests to them as well.
Regards, Steve McIntyre